It is true that the advent of technology, particularly smartphones and computers, has had a significant impact on people's handwriting skills. However, it is inaccurate to assume that messy handwriting is a recent phenomenon caused solely by technology. Messy handwriting has been observed throughout history, even centuries before the introduction of modern technology.

Here are some reasons why people have had messy handwriting throughout the ages:

1. Lack of Standardization: In the past, there was no universal standard for handwriting. Different regions, countries, and cultures had their own distinct writing styles. This led to a wide variation in handwriting, with some people naturally having messier handwriting than others.

2. Writing Implements: The writing tools available in the past, such as quill pens and inkwells, often required more skill and precision to use effectively. Factors like the type of ink, pen nib, and paper quality could affect the legibility of handwriting.

3. Education and Literacy: In historical times, not everyone had access to formal education. This resulted in a significant portion of the population being illiterate or having limited writing skills, leading to messier handwriting.

4. Speed and Efficiency: In certain professions and situations, speed and efficiency were prioritized over neatness. This could result in people writing quickly, leading to less legible handwriting.

5. Personal Style and Handwriting Development: Handwriting is influenced by personal style and the development of individual writing habits over time. Some people naturally have more stylized or idiosyncratic handwriting, which may appear messier to others.

While technology may have contributed to a decline in overall penmanship skills, it is essential to recognize that messy handwriting has existed long before the digital age and is influenced by various factors throughout history.